-->
EF Big Dog
Go Back   Extreme Fitness » Training » Bodybuilding and Strength Training


Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools

How low on bench and shoulder press?
Old August 25th, 2008, 10:32 PM   #1 (permalink)
Adamo
Senior Member
 
offline
Join Date: Jul 2004
Posts: 291
Thanks given: 63
238 thanks in 62 posts
Rep Power: 6
Adamo says People Like Me
Default How low on bench and shoulder press?

I've been getting different info about how low I should go with the bar when doing barbell bench presses and doing dumbbell shoulder presses. I thought I read somewhere that going too low can put stress on the rotator cuff.

On the bench should I be lowering the bar down so that it touches my chest?

And, on the dumbbell shoulder presses should my upper arm go below horizontal?

Any input would be appreciated

thanks
 
3 users said Thanks:
Insex (August 26th, 2008), skijumpbump (August 27th, 2008), wildstang (August 28th, 2008)


Old August 25th, 2008, 10:47 PM   #2 (permalink)
tooncesthecat
Browns Backer
Top Dog
 
tooncesthecat's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Southern Ohio
Posts: 2,176
Thanks given: 9,119
8,261 thanks in 1,838 posts
Rep Power: 20
tooncesthecat is an EF Big Dogtooncesthecat is an EF Big Dogtooncesthecat is an EF Big Dogtooncesthecat is an EF Big Dogtooncesthecat is an EF Big Dogtooncesthecat is an EF Big Dogtooncesthecat is an EF Big Dog
Default

Yes and yes. You should have no problems from going to your chest and below parallel unless you have some existing shoulder trouble. Just use light weight if you are not used to either of these movements until you build up proper strength in the shoulders. Do some rotator cuff exercises.
 
3 users said Thanks:
Insex (August 26th, 2008), skijumpbump (August 27th, 2008), wildstang (August 28th, 2008)

Old August 25th, 2008, 10:49 PM   #3 (permalink)
wil
Right-Wing Wacko
Top Dog
 
wil's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: South-Central Pennsylvania
Posts: 2,678
Thanks given: 4,314
5,104 thanks in 1,834 posts
Rep Power: 15
wil is an EF Big Dogwil is an EF Big Dogwil is an EF Big Dogwil is an EF Big Dogwil is an EF Big Dogwil is an EF Big Dog
Default

Yes to both.
 
4 users said Thanks:
Insex (August 26th, 2008), skijumpbump (August 27th, 2008), tooncesthecat (August 26th, 2008), wildstang (August 28th, 2008)

Old August 26th, 2008, 07:14 AM   #4 (permalink)
katz7479
No Pain No Gain
 
katz7479's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: ohio
Posts: 236
Thanks given: 79
333 thanks in 165 posts
Rep Power: 2
katz7479 says People REALLY Like Me
Send a message via AIM to katz7479
Default

heres a tip if I am guessing why you have asked this because at your gym you see the half rep'rs the guys that ethier go half up or half down on the bench the best way to learn about lifts is using this link. I have learnd alot from this website and have correctd my form in a variety fo lifts.

Bodybuilding.com - #1 Exercises Guide - Over 300 Exercises!

like i said great website
 
5 users said Thanks:
A1food4U (August 26th, 2008), Insex (August 26th, 2008), skijumpbump (August 27th, 2008), tooncesthecat (August 26th, 2008), wildstang (August 28th, 2008)

Old August 27th, 2008, 02:47 PM   #5 (permalink)
painless2
Moderator
 
painless2's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Arizona!
Posts: 2,105
Thanks given: 92
722 thanks in 359 posts
Rep Power: 20
painless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dog
Default

Go down to where is comfortable for you. I go to slightly below a basic parallel on bench as there is little extra benefit from going deeper and with shoulder presses it's about the same.
 
4 users said Thanks:
Insex (August 30th, 2008), skijumpbump (August 27th, 2008), tooncesthecat (August 27th, 2008), wildstang (August 28th, 2008)

Old August 27th, 2008, 03:17 PM   #6 (permalink)
skijumpbump
Member
 
skijumpbump's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 64
Thanks given: 40
54 thanks in 30 posts
Rep Power: 4
skijumpbump says People Like Me
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by katz7479 View Post
half rep'rs the guys that ethier go half up
I like to do this some times to really target the chest, I don't recommend doing this on every set of all of your bench presses, but it is a good way to not involve the triceps and just hit your chest for a good burn after all of your work sets.

What I HATE are the guys who load up the bar with tons of weight and then only lower it about six inches on every rep. To the OP, please don’t be one of those guys. For most bench sets lower the bar to your chest in a slow controlled manner until it touches your chest, pause for a second, then press it up with power.
 
3 users said Thanks:
Insex (August 30th, 2008), tooncesthecat (August 27th, 2008), wildstang (August 28th, 2008)

Old August 27th, 2008, 06:17 PM   #7 (permalink)
Carnitas
EF Big Dog
Big Dog
 
Carnitas's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: May 2006
Location: So Cal
Posts: 460
Thanks given: 182
598 thanks in 219 posts
Rep Power: 7
Carnitas is an EF Big DogCarnitas is an EF Big DogCarnitas is an EF Big DogCarnitas is an EF Big Dog
Send a message via AIM to Carnitas
Default

Also, don't bounce it off your chest! I hate when I see guys doing that. Its fine to lower it to your chest, and even have the bar touching, but don't use your chest to bounce it up so its easier to lift the bar.
 
3 users said Thanks:
Insex (August 30th, 2008), tooncesthecat (August 27th, 2008), wildstang (August 28th, 2008)

Old August 27th, 2008, 07:46 PM   #8 (permalink)
Steel_UK
Member
 
offline
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 94
Thanks given: 30
157 thanks in 64 posts
Rep Power: 3
Steel_UK says People Like Me
Default

I bring the bar down to my chest under normal benching, and on the dumbbell shoulder pressing I bring the dumbbells down till they touch my shoulders.
 
3 users said Thanks:
Insex (August 30th, 2008), tooncesthecat (September 7th, 2008), wildstang (August 28th, 2008)

Old August 29th, 2008, 07:55 AM   #9 (permalink)
torofuerte
deadlift jitsu!
Big Dog
 
torofuerte's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: Apr 2007
Posts: 348
Thanks given: 136
923 thanks in 274 posts
Rep Power: 6
torofuerte is an EF Big Dogtorofuerte is an EF Big Dogtorofuerte is an EF Big Dogtorofuerte is an EF Big Dog
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Adamo View Post
I've been getting different info about how low I should go with the bar when doing barbell bench presses and doing dumbbell shoulder presses. I thought I read somewhere that going too low can put stress on the rotator cuff.

On the bench should I be lowering the bar down so that it touches my chest?

And, on the dumbbell shoulder presses should my upper arm go below horizontal?

Any input would be appreciated

thanks

It can, but only if you never take care of working the antagonistics, the external shoulder rotators (infraspinatus and teres major), the internal shoulder rotator muscle (subscapularis), the supraspinatus and the serratus anterior as well as maintaining flexibility on your external shoulder rotators, pec minors and upper thoraccic mobility.

Simple test: Wall Shoulder Girdle Stretch

If a person has difficulty doing that, or if he/she sees that one arm is more inflexible than the other, chances are that the person is well on his way of shoulder problems... even if he/she doesn't feel any pain right now.

Shoulder problem does not occur overnight, nor of pressing, but of a long and continuous pattern of an excess of pressing/pushing exercises in relation to pulling exercises.

You need to keep a ration of 2:1 on pulling in relation to pushing to maintain long-term health of the shoulder. And by pulling I don't mean just barbell rows or pull ups/pull downs, but on active external rotation pulling like face pulls.

The shoulder and shoulder blades have 4 basic ranges of movement:

1. Protraction - pushing forward and "shrugging" your shoulders forwards, as in push ups, push up "plus" and plyometric push ups.

2. Retraction - when you retract the shoulder blades on the top of a row (or when you retract them in preparation for a bench press.)

3. Elevation - shrugs.

4. Depression - the bottom part of a dip pushing the shoulders further down.

Now, the bench press is a funny animal. You push, but you do not perform protraction. You retract your shoulder blades for safety (if you don't, you are a moron, you are going to nuke your shoulders.)

Then people try to balance that "pushing" movement with, say, rows (which also do retraction) or pull downs (which do not much retraction or protraction at all.)

So, even if you are trying to balance your pushes and your pulls, you are still doing predominant retraction movements with little protraction. This is another reason for shoulder pain on the long run.

Add push ups (either regular, pdepth or plyos or push up plus) on a regular basis. This adds protraction to your shoulder training. It's is an exercise that you can do pretty much every day. Depth push ups work your serratus anteriors (thus avoiding wing scapula syndrome.)

In addition to that, do face pulls and stretch your internal and external shoulder rotators ALWAYS. Never let those suckers get inflexible. Never.

And last but not least, aim to do a couple of sets of push ups on a medicine ball regularly. Make it part of your warm up everytime you go to the gym. The instability of the ball forces you to recruit not only the pushing muscles, but the antagonists. The added instability forces the shoulders to work as a whole, and since it's just a couple of sets, it won't drain you and turn detrimental to your training.

Then you can bench press almost any way you want without having to worry about fuckign up your shoulders.

If you have already messed them up, then you'll have to work around, avoid certain types of exercises. A messed up shoulder almost surely stays with you for life.
__________________
New to lifting? Get Mark Rippetoe's Starting Strength, 2nd Ed - me and tabatas

 
4 users said Thanks:
Insex (August 30th, 2008), orientalkid (September 8th, 2008), tooncesthecat (September 7th, 2008), wildstang (August 29th, 2008)

Old September 7th, 2008, 07:34 PM   #10 (permalink)
Cicero
Junior Member
 
offline
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Orion arm, Milky Way galaxy
Posts: 9
Thanks given: 15
2 thanks in 1 post
Rep Power: 0
Cicero is a Regular Joe
Default

As torofuerte says, you should keep your shoulders strong and protected. It's worth it to to the additional exercises to maintain shoulder health. Once you damage them, you will live with that for life.
 
2 users said Thanks:
Insex (September 19th, 2008), tooncesthecat (September 9th, 2008)

Old September 8th, 2008, 12:58 AM   #11 (permalink)
painless2
Moderator
 
painless2's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Arizona!
Posts: 2,105
Thanks given: 92
722 thanks in 359 posts
Rep Power: 20
painless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dog
Default

Never do what you're "supposed" to do, DO what is comfortable for you to do. There is so much BS and mythology in exercise, a person is their own best judge for whether something hurts, strains, pulls etc..., so use a comfortable range of motion that works for you, there is not perfect answer aside from that.
 
painless2 said Thanks
Insex (September 19th, 2008)

Old September 8th, 2008, 05:54 AM   #12 (permalink)
TommuGuns
EF Roid Muncher
Big Dog
 
TommuGuns's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Australia
Posts: 662
Thanks given: 258
922 thanks in 388 posts
Rep Power: 8
TommuGuns is an EF Big DogTommuGuns is an EF Big DogTommuGuns is an EF Big Dog
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by painless2 View Post
Never do what you're "supposed" to do, DO what is comfortable for you to do. There is so much BS and mythology in exercise, a person is their own best judge for whether something hurts, strains, pulls etc..., so use a comfortable range of motion that works for you, there is not perfect answer aside from that.
I disagree.... there a guys at the gym who dont even do a half rep and go super heavy cos they like to think they are lifting heavy weights. There are proper ways of training and wrong ways of training, its as simple as that.
 
TommuGuns said Thanks
Insex (September 19th, 2008)

Old September 8th, 2008, 11:29 AM   #13 (permalink)
painless2
Moderator
 
painless2's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Arizona!
Posts: 2,105
Thanks given: 92
722 thanks in 359 posts
Rep Power: 20
painless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dog
Default

My point remains that comfortable ROM is fine. Sure, by doing half reps you are not getting a complete recruitment of a muscle along its length, but it's just as silly to say that people must bring a bar to their chest during bench press, as it differs so much from person to person. If a guy wants to do half reps, let him, and if a guy wants to bring the bar to his chest, same thing. You get my point?
 
2 users said Thanks:
Insex (September 19th, 2008), orientalkid (September 8th, 2008)

Old September 9th, 2008, 04:12 AM   #14 (permalink)
TommuGuns
EF Roid Muncher
Big Dog
 
TommuGuns's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Australia
Posts: 662
Thanks given: 258
922 thanks in 388 posts
Rep Power: 8
TommuGuns is an EF Big DogTommuGuns is an EF Big DogTommuGuns is an EF Big Dog
Default

No i dont get ur point.... you can try justify poor form however u like. You are only lying to yourself, its your results which are going 2 suffer.

Just giving my opinion. There are right ways and wrong ways to train... there is no in between.
 
TommuGuns said Thanks
Insex (September 19th, 2008)

Old September 9th, 2008, 12:24 PM   #15 (permalink)
painless2
Moderator
 
painless2's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Arizona!
Posts: 2,105
Thanks given: 92
722 thanks in 359 posts
Rep Power: 20
painless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dogpainless2 is an EF Big Dog
Default

At what point did I advocate poor form? I think you know I never did, I simply said to use a comfortable range of motion. I'm pretty sure I know how to train. I think what you need to grasp is the concept of functional range of motion and absolute range of motion, the difference is dramatic and the amount of work done by the muscles targeted varies greatly.
 
painless2 said Thanks
Insex (September 19th, 2008)

Old September 9th, 2008, 02:55 PM   #16 (permalink)
Steel_UK
Member
 
offline
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 94
Thanks given: 30
157 thanks in 64 posts
Rep Power: 3
Steel_UK says People Like Me
Default

Another thing by the way TommuGuns, what about board benching? As that's not bringing the bar all the way down to the chest... So do you dislike that or what?
 
Steel_UK said Thanks
Insex (September 19th, 2008)

Old September 10th, 2008, 02:16 AM   #17 (permalink)
TommuGuns
EF Roid Muncher
Big Dog
 
TommuGuns's Avatar
 
offline
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Australia
Posts: 662
Thanks given: 258
922 thanks in 388 posts
Rep Power: 8
TommuGuns is an EF Big DogTommuGuns is an EF Big DogTommuGuns is an EF Big Dog
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by painless2 View Post
At what point did I advocate poor form? I think you know I never did, I simply said to use a comfortable range of motion. I'm pretty sure I know how to train. I think wha